| Category |
Decision |
Discussion_log
|
| Category:...And Oceans albums |
rename; have category redirect on Category:...And Oceans albums |
April 8
|
| Category:10th century BC |
nomination withdrawn. -- |
April 29
|
| Category:1906 IAAUS College football season |
rename to Category:1906 Intercollegiate Athletic Association of the United States football season, Category:1907 Intercollegiate Athletic Association of the United States football season, Category:1908 Intercollegiate Athletic Association of the United States football season, and Category:1909 Intercollegiate Athletic Association of the United States football season. |
April 2
|
| Category:1910 NCAA College football season |
rename as proposed; no consensus for expanding "NCAA". The consensus was not strong to drop "College", but the argument that it should be dropped is much stronger since the majority of the later NCAA football seasons in Category:College football seasons do not contain "College" in the name. It is indeed a redundant word once "NCAA" is used. A future nomination could focus explicitly on whether or not "NCAA" should be expanded in these and all other categories where it is used. |
April 2
|
| Category:1971 martyred intellectuals of Bangladesh |
rename to Category:People killed in the Bangladesh Liberation War, noting the convention of similar categories in Category:War-related deaths and that the main article and category are Bangladesh Liberation War and Category:Bangladesh Liberation War, respectively. While this was not one of the options proposed, I believe it captures what BrownHairedGirl and Peterkingiron intended; I applied the idea of "something along those lines" quite liberally, so please let me know if my assumption is incorrect. -- |
April 2
|
| Category:2005 in United States meteorology |
 Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 May 16 |
April 27
|
| Category:2006 in winter sports |
keep. — |
April 6
|
| Category:2007 in snowboarding |
merge to Category:Snowboarding and Category:2007 in sports. — |
April 11
|
| Category:2010 soundtracks |
merge to Category:Soundtrack albums and Category:2010 albums. — |
April 1
|
| Category:2010–11 A1 Grand Prix season |
Delete |
April 10
|
| Category:20th-century people by nationality |
keep as a container category. It may or may not be possible in theory for a container category to constitute overcategorization, but this was not demonstrated to be the case in this instance. -- |
April 24
|
| Category:20th-century rulers of constituent or unrecognized states in Oceania |
delete. -- |
April 26
|
| Category:21st-century bishops of the Episcopal Church in the United States of America |
merge all. — |
April 16
|
| Category:21st-century South Korean people |
delete. — |
April 16
|
| Category:3D fighting games |
keep. — |
April 14
|
| Category:9/11 conspiracy theorists |
keep. — |
April 24
|
| Category:9/11-related legal issues |
rename. — |
April 24
|
| Category:900s BC |
nomination withdrawn. -- |
April 29
|
| Category:A.S.C. member |
Listify. Since the list was created under the name suggested below, this becomes a Delete |
April 11
|
| Category:A.S.C. member |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 11 |
April 3
|
| Category:ABUSERS Intervention Reality Series |
delete. -- |
April 26
|
| Category:Acadian film |
keep. — |
April 25
|
| Category:Acoustic music albums |
delete |
April 19
|
| Category:Adherents to the British-Irish voluntary code of conduct |
delete. — |
April 7
|
| Category:Adult-oriented cartoons |
delete. — |
April 20
|
| Category:Airfields of the United States Army Air Forces in the Rocky Mountains Region |
Split into appropriate subcategories of Category:Airfields of the United States Army Air Forces in the United States by state |
April 9
|
| Category:Al Ain FC players |
Rename |
April 23
|
| Category:All Blacks |
rename to Category:New Zealand international rugby union players. -- |
April 4
|
| Category:All-Japan Grand Touring Car Championship drivers |
merge. — |
April 13
|
| Category:All-Japan Grand Touring Car Championship drivers |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 13 |
April 6
|
| Category:Alt-country musicians by instrument |
rename. — |
April 7
|
| Category:Alumni of the University of Cambridge (Unknown College) |
Upmerge |
April 2
|
| Category:Ambient albums |
Keep |
April 6
|
| American criminals |
Rename |
April 8
|
| Category:American expatriates in Puerto Rico |
delete. — |
April 16
|
| Category:American expatriates in Puerto Rico |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 16#Category:American expatriates in Puerto Rico. — |
April 1
|
| Category:American female journalists |
keep. — |
April 3
|
| Category:American Jewish people |
rename. — |
April 29
|
| Category:American journalists by type of media |
Merge |
April 3
|
| Category:American Major League Baseball players by home state |
rename. — |
April 23
|
| Category:American online journalists |
keep. — |
April 16
|
| Category:American Professors of English |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 May 6#Category:American Professors of English. — |
April 19
|
| Category:Americans convicted of child pornography |
Rename to Category:People convicted of child pornography offenses, and expand the scope to include all nationalities. The current contents will also be added to Category:American sex offenders |
April 8
|
| Ancient Rome |
no consensus. — |
April 1
|
| Category:Anglican bishops by diocese in the United Kingdom |
upmerge as nominated |
April 19
|
| Category:Anglican bishops by diocese outside the United Kingdom |
merge |
April 19
|
| Category:Anglican Church of New Zealand |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 May 18#Category:Anglican Church of New Zealand. — |
April 28
|
| Category:Anglo-Nunavummiut |
delete both. — |
April 25
|
| Category:Angolan people of Black African descent |
delete. Merging to Category:Angolan people is not needed as all of the articles are already in one or more subcategories (or subcategories of those) of Category:Angolan people. -- |
April 3
|
| Category:Appearances by Eminem |
delete all. -- |
April 4
|
| Category:Arista Records |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 May 16 |
April 27
|
| Category:Articles in need of serious revision |
Merge into Category:Wikipedia articles needing rewrite |
April 2
|
| Category:Asian American theatre directors |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 May 16#Category:Asian American theatre directors. — |
April 17
|
| Category:Association football lists by country |
rename. — |
April 23
|
| Category:Association football lists by country |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 23#Category:Association football lists by country. — |
April 6
|
| Category:Australian rugby league teams |
keep. — |
April 6
|
| Category:Authors writing in dialects from England |
Keep and repopulate |
April 7
|
| Category:Awards and decorations of The Sri Lanka Police |
merge. — |
April 11
|
| Category:Awards and decorations of The Sri Lanka Police |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 11 |
April 2
|
| Category:B-side collections |
Rename as nominated |
April 4
|
| Category:Band-centric video games |
no consensus. No prejudice against speedy renomination |
April 20
|
| Category:Band-centric video games |
 Relisted, see Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 20#Category:Band-centric video games. -- |
April 12
|
| Category:Band-centric video games |
Relisted, see Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 12#Category:Band-centric video games. By the way, I noticed that this category is both a subcategory of and a parent to Category:Musician video games. -- |
April 3
|
| Category:Barefootedness |
delete. — |
April 28
|
| Category:Basketball players from Chicago, Illinois |
merge. — |
April 2
|
| Category:Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar |
Rename |
April 3
|
| Category:Blyth Spartans F.C. |
rename all. — |
April 12
|
| Bobby Valentino |
Rename both |
April 6
|
| Category:Bolehall Swifts F.C. |
delete |
April 20
|
| Category:Books which are set within one day |
keep |
April 23
|
| Category:Braniff |
Keep |
April 20
|
| Category:Braniff |
Relisted, see Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 20#Category:Braniff. -- |
April 12
|
| Category:British cabinetmakers |
merge. — |
April 1
|
| Category:BUETian Wikipedians |
rename as nominated; limit to alumni |
April 7
|
| Category:Building Information Modeling |
rename |
April 27
|
| Category:C++ standard library |
rename to Category:C++ Standard Library. -- |
April 3
|
| Category:Calgary Cowboys (WHA) players |
Rename |
April 21
|
| Category:Canadian-born entertainers in the United States |
delete. — |
April 7
|
| Cars (film) |
rename to Category:Cars (film) and Category:Cars (film) characters. -- |
April 13
|
| Category:Categorization (Manual of Style) |
Speedied as per creator's tag |
April 24
|
| Cemeteries in Riverside County, California |
Delete |
April 18
|
| Category:Cerebrovascular disease |
speedy delete (criterion C1). -- |
April 26
|
| Category:Charlotte Hornets (minors) players |
merge. — |
April 6
|
| Category:Chicagoland railroads |
rename to Category:Railroads in the Chicago Switching District |
April 7
|
| Category:Chinese American philosophers |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 May 16 |
April 16
|
| Category:Christian conspiracy theorists |
rename to Category:Christianity conspiracy theorists. — |
April 16
|
| Category:CIS Men's Soccer Championship |
rename. — |
April 13
|
| Category:Cities and towns in the Saarpfalz |
Delete |
April 10
|
| Category:Cities, towns and villages in Abkhazia |
rename and delete as nominated. — |
April 28
|
| Category:Climate Feedbacks |
no consensus to delete; renaming to Category:Climate feedbacks to fix caps per speedy critierion C2A. I suggest that a category definition be added and/or a new discussion be held with less technical lingo being used. |
April 20
|
| Category:CMX |
rename. — |
April 14
|
| Category:CNC, CAD, and CAM |
rename |
April 27
|
| Category:College baseball seasons |
rename, invoking WP:SILENCE. — |
April 16
|
| Category:Colombian-American models |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 May 16 |
April 17
|
| Category:Comics articles that need real world chronology |
delete. -- |
April 26
|
| Category:Communist terrorism in India |
delete. — |
April 12
|
| Category:Communities by occupation |
rename |
April 12
|
| Category:Compact Disc and DVD copy protection |
rename to Category:Optical disc copy protection. -- |
April 4
|
| Category:Companies based in Columbus, Ohio |
rename |
April 7
|
| Category:Companies based in New Albany, Ohio |
merge to Category:Companies based in the Columbus, Ohio metropolitan area. There's a consensus here that the category should be merged to something broader, the debate revolved around what that would be. In light of the recent creation of the broad Category:Companies based in the Columbus, Ohio metropolitan area via another CFD, as noted by postdlf and Vegaswikian, this appears to be the logical solution at least for the time being. |
April 5
|
| Category:Companies based in Oklahoma City |
SPEEDY DELETE; copy of text already at List of companies based in Oklahoma City; category is otherwise empty and duplicate of already-populated category. |
April 1
|
| Category:Companies operating in Israeli-occupied territories |
delete. There was not enough support to repurpose the category. — |
April 1
|
| Category:Companies with economic ties to Israeli-occupied territories |
deletion |
April 1
|
| Category:Compilation albums |
keep. — |
April 4
|
| Category:Compilations |
delete. — |
April 20
|
| Category:Compilations |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 20#Category:Compilations. — |
April 5
|
| Category:CONCACAF U-20 Championship |
rename. — |
April 13
|
| Category:Consolidated City and Counties in the United States |
rename to Category:Consolidated city–counties in the United States. — |
April 10
|
| Category:Converts to Orthodox independent denominations from Eastern Orthodoxy |
delete both. -- |
April 22
|
| Convicted bigamists |
Don't rename |
April 8
|
| Convicted child molesters |
Rename. Follows the pattern in the nomination above |
April 8
|
| Category:Cornish immigrants to the United States |
merge. — |
April 22
|
| Category:Costa Ricans of Russian descent |
keep, speedy rename (criterion C2.C) to Category:Costa Rican people of Russian descent. -- |
April 12
|
| Category:Counties and municipal districts of Alberta |
rename to Category:Municipal districts and counties in Alberta. -- |
April 21
|
| Category:Country albums |
no consensus to rename, as the arguments for over-disambiguating these categories were valid concerns that were not addressed. I would suggest in engaging in discussion with WikiProject Music and/or WikiProject Music genres to further examine this issue with all genre-related categories as these listed below to and come to a consensus as to where disambiguation would be best. — |
April 4
|
| Category:Country singers |
no consensus to rename, as the arguments for over-disambiguating these categories were valid concerns that were not addressed. I would suggest in engaging in discussion with WikiProject Music and/or WikiProject Music genres to further examine this issue with all genre-related categories as these listed below to and come to a consensus as to where disambiguation would be best. — |
April 4
|
| Category:County buildings in the United States |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 May 21#Category:County buildings in the United States. — |
April 16
|
| Category:Cuban-American architects |
Upmerge to Category:American people of Cuban descent and Category:American architects |
April 28
|
| Category:Cuban-American architects |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 28 |
April 18
|
| Category:Cult classic films |
SPEEDY DELETE as recreation. |
April 1
|
| Category:Curly bracket programming languages |
delete/merge. I will manually upmerge any page which would be left uncategorized. -- |
April 2
|
| Category:Deaths by beating |
keep. -- |
April 4
|
| Category:Depictions of Canada |
Delete |
April 30
|
| Category:Disused railway stations in central London |
Upmerge into Category:Disused railway stations in London |
April 5
|
| Category:Disused railway stations in the United Kingdom |
keep. — |
April 1
|
| Category:Dominionist organizations |
delete: uncontested and well-reasoned nomination. -- |
April 3
|
| Category:Doomsday films |
No consensus to merge |
April 7
|
| Category:Download albums |
rename to Category:Download (band) albums. — |
April 7
|
| Category:Drinking establishments on the National Register of Historic Places in Massachusetts |
merge to Category:National Register of Historic Places in Massachusetts and a new Category:Drinking establishments on the National Register of Historic Places |
April 4
|
| Category:Editors mentioned in The World and Wikipedia |
delete. — |
April 7
|
| Category:Emerald Bowl |
no consensus. The creation of subcategories is better left to editorial discretion, with them being brought to CfD is anyone thinks it is necessary |
April 26
|
| Category:English expatriates in Scotland |
delete, noting that each article is also present in Category:English expatriate footballers and Category:Expatriate footballers in Scotland or Category:Scottish expatriate footballers and Category:Expatriate footballers in England. -- |
April 3
|
| Category:European Alpine regions |
delete |
April 15
|
| Category:Eurovision Song Contest entrants of 2001 |
Relisted at 2010 MAY 5 CFD. |
April 15
|
| Category:Expatriate football coaches in South Korea |
merge. — |
April 1
|
| Category:Family Office |
delete. -- |
April 29
|
| Category:Fan club releases |
rename to Category:Fan-club-release albums. I believe the grammar of the hyphens is correct, as explained by |
April 5
|
| Category:Farm preservationists |
delete. — |
April 21
|
| Category:Fear before the March of Flames albums |
rename. — |
April 12
|
| Category:FEI World Cup Jumping 2008–09 |
Delete |
April 12
|
| Category:FEI World Cup Jumping 2008–09 |
Relisted, see Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 12#Category:FEI World Cup Jumping 2008–09. The category was not tagged for deletion. -- |
April 4
|
| Category:Fictional Jews |
procedural keep, following the outcome of this discussion. Should the nominator or any other editor feel that the category be deleted or renamed and/or re-scoped, please nominate the category for deletion or renaming at the current day of the CFD page. — |
April 7
|
| Category:Fictional truck drivers |
merge Category:Fictional truckers to Category:Fictional truck drivers. — |
April 14
|
| Category:FIFA video game series |
Rename |
April 14
|
| Category:Films starring the director |
delete. — |
April 17
|
| Category:Films which are set within one day |
keep |
April 23
|
| Category:Films with two parts |
Delete |
April 28
|
| Category:Financial information |
Rename to Category:Financial data vendors. There is consensus to rename, albeit some discussion about the name. Since {{:financial data vendor]] appears to be the main article and the other pages are companies, Category:Financial data vendors would appear to be the best choice. If the category needs an introduction to further clarify the scope, others can add it |
April 20
|
| Category:Financial information |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 20#Category:Financial information. — |
April 5
|
| Category:Food and drink user templates |
delete, noting that the project userbox is in both Category:WikiProject Food and drink templates and Category:WikiProject user templates. -- |
April 11
|
| FOOian Singaporeans |
rename and merge as nominated. — |
April 20
|
| Category:Football (soccer) in Australia |
no consensus |
April 26
|
| Category:Football (soccer) in South Africa |
rename. — |
April 26
|
| Category:Football (soccer) informal variants |
Merge |
April 21
|
| Category:Football (soccer) informal variants |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 21 |
April 13
|
| Football (soccer) players by types of national teams |
rename reflecting option B. — |
April 29
|
| Category:Football (soccer) players |
speedy rename. There have been a lot of these going through WP:CFDS lately; that's probably the best forum for them at this stage now that a naming convention for A.F. categories seems to have been settled on. |
April 14
|
| Category:Football players of Turkish descent |
Delete |
April 29
|
| Category:Footer and header message boxes |
delete |
April 19
|
| Category:Formula One drivers killed while racing |
merge. — |
April 6
|
| Futsal competitions by country |
Rename all |
April 14
|
| Category:Fuzhou people |
rename |
April 29
|
| Category:G'$ Up artists |
Delete |
April 17
|
| Gangs and Organized crime in Chile |
delete |
April 20
|
| Category:Gargoyle albums |
speedily deleted by creator and sole editor, |
April 28
|
| Category:Gender-inclusive language |
rename to Category:Gender-neutral language. -- |
April 26
|
| Category:Geological Surveys |
rename. As it was noted several times, collectively, the term "Geological surveys" is not a proper noun. In fact, I should point out that the main article, geological survey, uses lower-capitalization as well. — |
April 23
|
| Category:Gersheim |
Delete |
April 10
|
| Category:Giant Records (Warner Bros. subsidiary label) albums |
rename both. — |
April 11
|
| Category:Golf Wives and Girlfriends |
Delete |
April 17
|
| Category:Gordon J. Laing Award |
delete. — |
April 22
|
| Category:Government buildings in the United States |
no consensus to rename. — |
April 16
|
| Category:Graphical MUDs |
Keep. Apparently the terms aren't quite as synonymous as stated in the nomination |
April 25
|
| Category:Greater London |
delete. — |
April 13
|
| Category:Grendizer series characters |
merge |
April 20
|
| Category:Grindhouse films |
delete. -- |
April 12
|
| Category:Hate groups |
listify Category:Hate groups in the United States and delete Category:Hate groups (nothing to listify). -- |
April 10
|
| Category:Heathcliff |
rename to Category:Heathcliff (comic strip). — |
April 28
|
| Category:Hernia images |
Delete |
April 24
|
| Category:Heroes turned bad |
delete. — |
April 2
|
| Category:Hispanic American people |
rename |
April 17
|
| Category:Hispanic American |
rename to Category:Hispanic and Latino American. — |
April 17
|
| Category:Hispanic culture in the United States |
merge all 3 into Category:Hispanic and Latino American culture as nominated |
April 17
|
| Category:History of the National Register of Historic Places |
merge to Category:National Register of Historic Places so that the single article is not left uncategorized. -- |
April 4
|
| Category:Hollywood families |
rename to Category:Show business families, without prejudice to a future nomination for deletion |
April 19
|
| Category:Hollywood families |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 19#Category:Hollywood families. — |
April 6
|
| Holy Week Lasallian Missions |
delete all. — |
April 2
|
| Category:Iconic city statues |
delete, as the category is highly subjective. — |
April 16
|
| Category:Images of Pikachu |
merge to Category:Pokémon images. -- |
April 21
|
| Category:Independent Spirit Award winners |
keep. — |
April 17
|
| Category:Indian American physicists |
Upmerge to Category:American physicists and Category:American people of Indian descent |
April 28
|
| Category:Indian American physicists |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 28 |
April 21
|
| Category:Indian hill stations |
rename. — |
April 17
|
| Category:Indian women journalists |
keep. — |
April 3
|
| Category:International Soccer League (1960-1965) |
rename (appears to be uncontroversial now that article name has changed) |
April 15
|
| Category:Investigative bloggers |
delete, with no prejudice against recreation if solid evidence can be produced which indicates that "investigative bloggers" are a recognized subgroup of bloggers as a whole and we have articles about individuals who are identified as investigative bloggers in reliable sources. There is no need to merge as all of the articles are already in a subcategory of Category:Bloggers (specifically, Category:American bloggers). -- |
April 3
|
| Category:Iranian-American actors |
merge to Category:American people of Iranian descent and Category:American actors of Asian descent |
April 15
|
| Category:Israeli companies operating in the occupied territories |
Speedy Delete as a recreation of deleted content and as an empty category. Also for this nomination WP:SNOW |
April 22
|
| Category:Jacques Cartier |
delete |
April 16
|
| Category:Jews from Selanik |
merge to Category:Jews from Thessaloniki. As the other categories were not tagged, they may be nominated for merging in a subsequent nomination. -- |
April 12
|
| Category:Josei |
rename all. -- |
April 21
|
| Category:Joseph Campbell |
delete |
April 22
|
| Category:Judaising Jerusalem |
delete |
April 20
|
| Category:Juno Award winners |
Withdrawn |
April 28
|
| Category:Juno Awards |
withdrawn by nominator. — |
April 28
|
| Category:Korean mass murderers |
speedy delete (criterion G7). FYI: Editors can request speedy deletion of pages to which they are the sole or primary contributor by adding {{db-author}} to the page. -- |
April 30
|
| Category:Lakes of the Pirin |
No consensus |
April 13
|
| Category:Last hitter of the World Series |
delete. — |
April 6
|
| Category:Leningrad school of painting |
delete, colleagues |
April 8
|
| Category:LGBT rights opposition |
do not rename, though I believe that there is a need for additional discussion and consideration of relevant issues |
April 12
|
| Category:Life after death |
rename |
April 15
|
| Category:List of Argentinean operas |
delete. — |
April 16
|
| Category:List of Big 12 college football head coaches |
rename. — |
April 7
|
| Category:Lists of awards by film |
no consensus to rename. — |
April 23
|
| Category:Lists of memorials |
rename to Category:Lists of monuments and memorials. -- |
April 24
|
| Category:Logic work group articles |
delete. — |
April 4
|
| Category:London Racers |
delete, as the category in question is unlikely to grow beyond its current point. — |
April 8
|
| Category:Luparense C5 |
Delete Category:Luparense C5, Rename Category:Luparense C5 players |
April 13
|
| Category:Malaysian people of mixed descent |
Delete |
April 12
|
| Category:Maldivian national football teams |
nomination withdrawn. -- |
April 15
|
| Category:Manual of Style |
Rename |
April 26
|
| Category:Medavie EMS |
speedy delete (criterion C1). -- |
April 26
|
| Category:Media adapted from a television series |
rename all |
April 24
|
| Category:Medicine (Manual of Style) |
speedy delete (criteria G7 and C1). -- |
April 26
|
| Category:Melanie albums |
rename as nominated. The category can be set to sort to the "M"s and if the name ever changes, so too can the applicable categories that apply to her. |
April 6
|
| Category:Members of the Polish Sejm |
rename. — |
April 12
|
| Category:Metro Toronto |
rename to Category:Metropolitan Toronto |
April 9
|
| Category:Metro Toronto |
Relisted, see Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 9#Category:Metro Toronto. -- |
April 1
|
| Category:Mexican American Major League Baseball players |
rename. — |
April 29
|
| Category:Models |
Rename Category:Models to Category:Models (occupation). |
April 29
|
| Category:Mortgage-backed security |
keep. — |
April 28
|
| Category:Mortgage-backed security |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 28 |
April 18
|
| Category:Motion comics |
delete. May be re-created in the future if there is a rough consensus that it is needed. |
April 4
|
| Category:Motown Records albums |
rename |
April 24
|
| Category:Motown Records artists |
rename; a broader nomination would be needed to change the standard naming convention for these types of categories |
April 24
|
| Category:Multi Family Office |
delete. -- |
April 29
|
| Category:Multi-User Dungeons |
rename. — |
April 7
|
| Category:Multiple engine aircraft |
rename |
April 23
|
| Category:Municipal districts and county seats in Alberta |
Merge to Category:Municipal seats in Alberta |
April 21
|
| Category:Museums in Lincoln, Lincolnshire |
keep. — |
April 2
|
| Category:Music charts |
delete (category has remained empty) |
April 15
|
| Category:Music documentary films |
rename. — |
April 2
|
| Category:Musta Surma albums |
delete. — |
April 12
|
| Category:Musta Surma albums |
Relisted, see Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 12#Category:Musta Surma albums. -- |
April 3
|
| Category:National Futsal League |
rename to Category:National futsal leagues. — |
April 13
|
| National subcategories of Category:Formula One people |
merge and delete as nominated. — |
April 6
|
| NCAA Division I basketball categories |
Rename all |
April 21
|
| Category:Nebraska entertainers |
rename. Indeed this could have been speedied originally |
April 14
|
| Category:Nebraska entertainers |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 14 |
April 7
|
| Category:Neighbourhoods in Thane |
keep. Thaneboy (talk · contribs) has populated the category with 12 articles, making the this nomination invalid. — |
April 23
|
| Category:Newcastle Falcons players |
rename to Category:Newcastle Falcons (basketball) players. — |
April 29
|
| Category:NF-Board football teams |
rename reflecting the second option in all instances. — |
April 20
|
| Category:NHL Network (1975-1979 version) affiliates |
rename to Category:The NHL Network (1975–79) affiliates, no consensus at this time to expand the abbreviation. -- |
April 11
|
| Category:Nigerian female basketball players |
rename. — |
April 17
|
| Category:Nike JOGA3 teams |
merge. — |
April 13
|
| Category:Nonfiction |
merge to Category:Non-fiction. The subcategories mentioned by Occuli will, as a result of this discussion, become eligible for renaming/merging to the hyphenated form under criterion C2.C, and I will list them at the speedy renaming page once the merging is carried out. -- |
April 3
|
| Category:North African Populated Israelis Settlements |
delete |
April 25
|
| Norwegian local politicians by county |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 May 21#Norwegian local politicians by county. — |
April 16
|
| Category:Norwegian people of 1905 |
delete, but merge contents into the article Dissolution of the union between Norway and Sweden in 1905. This will need more work in the article to prevent it from being just a simply list of important figures |
April 16
|
| Category:Novotel Hotels Hong Kong |
delete. Category has also remained empty. |
April 15
|
| Category:Official songs of US Territories |
Rename to Category:Anthems of insular areas of the United States |
April 25
|
| Category:Okataina Volcanic Center |
rename to Category:Okataina Volcanic Centre. Per Hugo999's suggestion, I have initiated a nomination for Category:Tongariro Volcanic Center; see here. -- |
April 29
|
| Category:Orators |
Delete all |
April 12
|
| Category:Organ disorders |
delete. -- |
April 29
|
| Category:Overseas Chinese by occupation |
rename |
April 17
|
| Category:Overseas Chinese groups |
merge. — |
April 28
|
| Category:Overseas Chinese groups |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 28 |
April 21
|
| Category:Overseas Fooian to Category Fooian diaspora |
merge |
April 16
|
| Category:Palestinian-American activists |
merge to Category:American activists and Category:American people of Palestinian descent. As noted, this category is not part of an established scheme within Category:Activists by issue; that being said, this discussion does not preclude the establishment of such a scheme. -- |
April 5
|
| Category:Pan Am |
do not rename. Perhaps it would be useful to create subcategories for each airline, and to place articles relating solely or primarily to one arline in the subcategory for that airline—if, that is, there are enough articles to warrant a three-way split. -- |
April 12
|
| Parent/grandparent categories |
Delete all |
April 7
|
| Parishes of Ireland |
Rename per nom and cleanup. The question is what it intended by the category and this is clearly pointed out in the introduction that it is for civil parishes. If religious parishes where to be included, that line would not be there. After the rename, the nominator and others will probably need to be doing some cleanup. I'll try and fix some of the parenting, but I may not have time to do it all. Delete Category:Parishes of the Republic of Ireland by county. Note that where religious parishes exist, the existing categories may be recreated with a less ambiguous name |
April 15
|
| Category:Parodies of Michael Jackson |
delete. — |
April 25
|
| Party ethnic groups in the United States |
delete/upmerge to American politicians by ethnicity categories, which are at this time Category:African American politicians, Category:American politicians of Cuban descent, Category:American politicians of Mexican descent, Category:Native Hawaiian politicians, and Category:Vietnamese-American politicians. |
April 19
|
| Category:Patricians |
rename to Category:Patricians (St Patrick's High School, Karachi). — |
April 20
|
| Category:PBR venues |
delete. — |
April 7
|
| Category:PBS Sports |
rename. There's been more than adequate time given for anyone to object to the proposal, which on its face sounds reasonable |
April 12
|
| Category:PBS Sports |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 12 —Preceding unsigned comment added by |
April 5
|
| Category:Penthouse magazine |
rename to Category:Penthouse (magazine). — |
April 16
|
| Category:People associated with the University of Johannesburg |
merge |
April 21
|
| Category:People from Central Province |
rename to Category:People from Central Province (Kenya). -- |
April 22
|
| Category:People from Eastern Province |
rename. — |
April 30
|
| Category:People from Esperanza |
rename |
April 16
|
| Category:People from Nyeri, Kenya |
rename to Category:People from Nyeri District. -- |
April 22
|
| Category:People from Okinawa |
rename. (I'll make Category:People from Okinawa a disambiguation category.) |
April 20
|
| Category:People from Okinawa |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 20#Category:People from Okinawa. — |
April 5
|
| Category:People from Saint-Isidore, Prescott and Russell |
merge to Category:People from Prescott and Russell, Ontario. — |
April 28
|
| Category:People from Surabaya, East Java |
rename. — |
April 13
|
| Category:People from Wanganui |
Rename |
April 13
|
| Category:People from Willemstad, Netherlands Antilles |
keep |
April 15
|
| Category:People from Willemstad, Netherlands Antilles |
keep. — |
April 6
|
| Category:People of Kohanim descent |
delete |
April 22
|
| Category:People with Wolff-Parkinson-White syndrome |
Delete |
April 6
|
| Category:People's Artists of Albania |
delete. -- |
April 14
|
| Playboy Playmates by decade |
rename all. — |
April 30
|
| Category:Political organizations based in Israel |
merge to Category:Political organizations in Israel, but I will note that this category was probably created for conformity with Category:Organizations based in Israel. No prejudice against a general nomination of the subcategories of Category:Political organizations by country to change in Foo to based in Foo. -- |
April 13
|
| Category:Political parties in Cornwall |
rename to Category:Cornish nationalist parties. -- |
April 26
|
| Category:Politics by continent subcategories |
keep Category:Politics of Asia and Category:Politics of Oceania and rename/merge the rest to Politics of Foo. Categories which were not tagged may be tagged with {{subst:cfr-speedy}} and processed under speedy renaming criterion C2.C. -- |
April 12
|
| Category:Popular musicians who committed suicide |
merge |
April 16
|
| Category:Prehistoric creatures of North America |
delete (category has remained empty) |
April 17
|
| Category:Presenters of the Royal Institution Christmas Lectures |
No consensus to delete |
April 2
|
| Category:Preservation |
rename. This will be renamed per nom, with absolutely no prejudice towards a follow-up nomination to change it to something else. There's a consensus here to change the name, and while there isn't a crystal clear decision to what it be changed to, one of the usual conventions is to use the name of the main article, which is supported by this discussion |
April 29
|
| Category:Prestige format comics |
delete. -- |
April 4
|
| Category:Prince (musician) internet releases |
upmerge to Category:Prince (musician) albums and Category:Internet albums |
April 7
|
| Category:Printing issues |
Delete |
April 28
|
| Category:Privately owned Government companies in India |
Speedy delete under G3 - Vandalism |
April 22
|
| Category:Privately owned Government companies in India |
Relisted, see Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 22#Category:Privately owned Government companies in India. At the moment, there is a weak preference to err on the side of caution and merely rename the category. To help to clarify consensus, I will relist this discussion again and notify WikiProject India, whose members may be able to offer relevant information. -- |
April 13
|
| Category:Pro Evolution Soccer |
rename. — |
April 14
|
| Category:Propositional logic |
rename as nominated. If the article ever gets moved back, the category of course could be re-nominated for naming back to the original name |
April 17
|
| Category:Protestant-related lists |
rename. — |
April 23
|
| Category:Pseudonymous album releases |
rename. — |
April 20
|
| Category:PSTN companies of Bangladesh |
Merge |
April 11
|
| Category:PSTN companies of Bangladesh |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 11 |
April 2
|
| Category:Rabbinic Kohanim |
delete. I am closing as "delete" instead of "upmerge" to avoid creating unnecessary recategorization work. Of the 21 article in this category, 16 already are in Category:Kohanim or Category:People of Kohanim descent. The remaining 5 articles—Abraham Isaac Kook, Dovid Leibowitz, Irving Greenberg, Ishmael ben Elisha ha-Kohen and Nesanel Quinn—may be added to either category as appropriate. -- |
April 11
|
| Category:Rabbinic Levites |
merge to Category:Levites. — |
April 11
|
| Category:Ranked Pairs |
delete. — |
April 25
|
| Category:RationalWikians |
delete |
April 22
|
| Category:RationalWikians |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 22 |
April 15
|
| Category:Relatives of L. Ron Hubbard |
rename to Category:L. Ron Hubbard family. — |
April 24
|
| Religion-related listings on the National Register |
rename the main category to Category:Properties of religious function on the National Register of Historic Places and the subcategories to Properties of religious function on the National Register of Historic Places in Foo |
April 1
|
| Category:Reuters Group plc |
rename |
April 7
|
| Category:Ribeiras of Cape Verde |
rename to Category:Rivers of Cape Verde. -- |
April 12
|
| Category:Rock Against Bush albums |
merge to Category:Fat Wreck Chords compilation albums (i.e., upmerge). -- |
April 3
|
| Category:Rugby league governing bodies |
upmerge Category:Rugby league governing bodies in the United Kingdom to Category:Rugby league governing bodies in Europe. If someone wants to nominate Category:Rugby league governing bodies in Europe for upmerging, this should be permitted. |
April 9
|
| Category:Russian and Soviet immigrants to Canada |
no consensus to delete. — |
April 30
|
| Category:Saarpfalz |
Delete |
April 10
|
| Category:Serbian propaganda |
keep. — |
April 1
|
| Settlements by population |
rename to Category:Transcendental Meditation communities and Category:Vegetarian communities. -- |
April 29
|
| Category:Settlements by year of disestablishment |
rename all. — |
April 28
|
| Category:Settlements in the Arctic |
rename to Category:Populated places in the Arctic. — |
April 28
|
| Category:Settlements |
Rename all as nominated, except that Category:Coastal settlements to Category:Populated coastal places |
April 17
|
| Category:Sex segregation |
Keep |
April 1
|
| Category:Silver Ferns |
rename to Category:New Zealand international netball players, and recreate as a category redirect. -- |
April 29
|
| Category:Single engine aircraft |
rename |
April 23
|
| Category:Soccer in New Zealand |
rename. — |
April 26
|
| Category:Socialist Labor Party |
rename to Category:Socialist Labor Party of America. -- |
April 3
|
| Category:SOiL albums |
rename to Category:Soil (band) albums. — |
April 7
|
| Category:Soils by country |
Rename. 07:24, 6 May 2010 (UTC) |
April 28
|
| Category:Soils by country |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 28 |
April 18
|
| Category:Songs with lyrics by Bobby Troup |
merge; seems to be a lack of interest or concern about this—in light of this, the nominator's proposal and the guidelines of WP:Songs should prevail. |
April 20
|
| Category:Songs with lyrics by Bobby Troup |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 20#Category:Songs with lyrics by Bobby Troup. — |
April 5
|
| Category:Songs with music by Mylène Farmer |
delete. Nothing to merge, as the category was emptied. — |
April 5
|
| Category:Songs written by Otis Williams (Temptations) |
rename |
April 15
|
| Category:Songs written by The Miracles members |
delete |
April 24
|
| Category:SourceForge games |
Delete |
April 10
|
| Category:South American Under 17 Championship |
Rename |
April 13
|
| Category:Spal 1907 players |
rename to Category:SPAL 1907 players. -- |
April 4
|
| Category:Spoken albums |
rename. — |
April 7
|
| Category:Sportspeople in New York (state) |
rename. — |
April 7
|
| Category:Sri Lankan Short Film Makers |
Speedy delete, creation of sockpuppet of banned user |
April 3
|
| Category:Stadia of the Commonwealth Games |
Rename |
April 5
|
| Stadia |
Rename both |
April 6
|
| Category:Steam aircraft |
rename |
April 20
|
| Category:Student ghettos |
no consensus |
April 20
|
| Category:Student ghettos |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 20#Category:Student ghettos. — |
April 5
|
| subcats of Category:People by religion |
keep all. — |
April 20
|
| Category:Tallac Records albums |
delete. — |
April 6
|
| Category:Taylor family |
Rename to Category:Zachary Taylor family |
April 7
|
| Television series episodes by season |
rename. (There was a suggestion that certain of these schemes should be upmerged due to a lack of contents. If desired, this can be pursued in a separate nomination and this close is without prejudice to future considerations of upmerging any of these categories. In other words, this discussion has merely decided that the proposed names are preferable; it hasn't made a decision as to the appropriateness of the existence of the categories as such.) |
April 8
|
| Category:Television shows with named seasons |
delete. -- |
April 22
|
| Category:Teochew Malaysians |
rename; in light of the lack of objections once this was moved from speedy, I think it's safe to rename. The extra time and exposure has served its purpose. I understand the anon's objection in the speedy section as being merely an objection to the use of the speedy procedure and not as an objection to the proposal as such. |
April 15
|
| Category:Terminal illness |
delete. -- |
April 29
|
| Category:Texas journalists by newspaper |
merge to both parents as nominated. -- |
April 3
|
| Category:The Essential |
no consensus. I have initiated a technical requested move discussion on the article's talk page to help to clarify consensus regarding the use of The Essential as a page title; see Talk:The Essential#Requested move. -- |
April 12
|
| Category:The Essential |
Relisted, see Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 12#Category:The Essential. -- |
April 3
|
| Category:The great Luke Ski albums |
rename. — |
April 13
|
| Category:The great Luke Ski albums |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 13 |
April 6
|
| Category:Thompson's albums |
delete. — |
April 2
|
| Category:Thongchai McIntyre |
delete. — |
April 3
|
| Category:Tom Yoda |
delete |
April 16
|
| Category:Tomás de Torrejón y Velsco |
delete. — |
April 28
|
| Category:Trade association |
merge both as suggested by Vegaswikian. Renaming sub-cats should be handled by a subsequent nomination |
April 29
|
| Category:Turkish-speaking countries and territories |
delete |
April 15
|
| Category:Turkmen people |
rename. — |
April 17
|
| Category:TV stub templates |
delete. — |
April 29
|
| Category:U.S. Northeast journalists |
merge all as nominated, with no prejudice against creating appropriate by-state categories. -- |
April 3
|
| Category:UK MPs 2005- |
rename |
April 6
|
| Category:Undrafted National Basketball Association players |
keep, with no prejudice against renominating to consider renaming. -- |
April 26
|
| Category:Undrafted National Football League players |
keep, with no prejudice against renominating to consider renaming. -- |
April 26
|
| Category:Undrafted National Hockey League players |
keep, with no prejudice against renominating to consider renaming. -- |
April 26
|
| Category:United Nations Advisory Committee on Administrative and Budgetary Questions (ACABQ) members |
Rename |
April 9
|
| Category:Untitled works |
delete. — |
April 12
|
| Category:Upper West Side (Manhattan) |
rename |
April 29
|
| Category:Upper West Side (Manhattan) |
Relisted, see Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 29#Category:Upper West Side (Manhattan). Category was not tagged. -- |
April 21
|
| Category:User BASIC-N |
delete. — |
April 7
|
| Category:User latex-0 |
Already speedy deleted by VegaDark as a recreation of deleted material (CSD G4) |
April 6
|
| Category:User latex-N |
delete. — |
April 7
|
| Category:User MathML-0 |
Delete |
April 6
|
| Category:User MathML-N |
delete. — |
April 7
|
| Category:User pcd-0 |
Delete |
April 6
|
| Category:User vhdl-N |
delete. — |
April 7
|
| Category:User XUL-0 |
Delete |
April 6
|
| Category:User XUL-N |
delete. — |
April 7
|
| Category:User:Koman90 |
speedy deleted per user request. |
April 21
|
| Category:User:Warregubbi |
Delete |
April 10
|
| Category:Users with new unsourced Biographies of Living People under review |
delete; doesn't look like a "breakthrough" is imminent in making this useful |
April 7
|
| Category:Vancouver Academy of Music |
delete. -- |
April 13
|
| Category:Vaporware operating systems |
delete. -- |
April 21
|
| Category:Video board games |
keep. — |
April 28
|
| Category:Video board games |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 28 |
April 18
|
| Category:Video game companies named after film production companies |
delete. -- |
April 13
|
| Category:Video game compilations |
rename. — |
April 20
|
| Category:Video game compilations |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 20#Category:Video game compilations. — |
April 5
|
| Category:Video games by location |
rename to Category:Video games by setting. -- |
April 3
|
| Category:Video games featuring female protagonists |
delete. There were many arguments brought forward by both sides of the discussion, and I believe those in favor of deletion had the upper hand. The category is in fact too broad; what constitutes as a playable "protagonist" is unclear and does not have a set definitive. Similar categories containing the term "protagonist" have been deleted in the past, most notably here and here, and nothing about this category's deletion is sexist, nor did it address the concern of the nominator and those who argued for its deletion. — |
April 12
|
| Category:Video games featuring Nazism |
delete. — |
April 19
|
| Category:Video games featuring Nazism |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 19 |
April 12
|
| Category:Visitor attractions in Greater Orlando |
keep |
April 20
|
| Category:Visitor attractions in Orange County, Florida |
keep. — |
April 28
|
| Category:Visitor attractions in Orlando, Florida |
no consensus. The discussion was complicated by the fact that there was a simultaneously held discussion regarding the category for visitor attractions in Greater Orlando on this same page. That discussion was closed as "keep". In light of that result, I suggest that it would be worthwhile to renominate this category now that the consensus is clear that Category:Visitor attractions in Greater Orlando should be kept. The new nomination should focus on whether we need both categories or just the one for Greater Orlando. |
April 20
|
| Voice actors by video game |
delete both. — |
April 16
|
| Category:Washington (U.S. state) |
Keep |
April 19
|
| Category:Washington, D.C., journalists by newspaper |
merge as nominated to both parents. -- |
April 3
|
| Western Asia |
do not rename. -- |
April 4
|
| Category:White |
Merge |
April 5
|
| Category:Whitegoods manufacturers of China |
rename to Category:Home appliance manufacturers of China. -- |
April 22
|
| Category:Who's Who in Nebraska 1940 |
Delete |
April 14
|
| Category:Wikipedia long term abuse |
speedy rename (criterion C2.A) to Category:Wikipedia long-term abuse. -- |
April 27
|
| Category:Wikipedia requested photographs in Computer hardware |
delete. — |
April 5
|
| Category:Wikipedian prophets |
Speedy delete as some sort of joke or hoax |
April 7
|
| Wikipedians by age (and subcategories) |
Delete |
April 7
|
| Category:Wikipedians by alma mater: Monta Vista High School |
delete. — |
April 7
|
| Category:Wikipedians in Tau Alpha Pi |
Delete |
April 10
|
| Category:Wikipedians who contribute to Memory Gamma |
delete |
April 22
|
| Category:Wikipedians who contribute to Memory Gamma |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 22 |
April 15
|
| Category:Wikipedians who contribute to the Club Penguin Wikis |
delete |
April 22
|
| Category:Wikipedians who contribute to the Club Penguin Wikis |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 April 22 |
April 15
|
| Category:Wikipedians who participated in iGEM |
Delete |
April 10
|
| Category:Wikipedians who use XChat |
Upmerge into Category:Wikipedians who use IRC |
April 8
|
| Category:WikiProject Azerbaijan members |
merge. — |
April 7
|
| Category:WikiProject Malta members |
Merge |
April 7
|
| Wildstorm Comics |
Rename. That was easy from the discussion. The problem is what to rename to. Wildstorm Publications seems to have the better case, so that is what the rename will be to. If anyone really thinks that there is a case to just use Wildstorm, I will not object if this is brought back here for a rename to drop Publications |
April 2
|
| Category:Works by Aoi Nishimata |
Delete |
April 22
|
| Category:World Series champions with both American and National League teams |
delete |
April 6
|
| Category:Yucky foods |
delete (why wait?). |
April 1
|
| Category:Yury Felten |
delete |
April 16
|
